Opinion Forum

How to Raise Spoiled Brats

February 22nd, 2011

In my consulting practice, I work with many families, both high-net-worth and those less affluent. I am constantly amazed at how nonchalant (or even downright neglectful) the parents are in their children’s fiscal education in both of these income groups. Despite the fact that many of the well-to-do parents grew up in less-affluent families themselves and their parents taught them to be fiscally responsible (which, by the way, probably contributed to their ability to create wealth) they are, more often than not, raising their children in precisely the opposite to the way they were raised.

Practices that foster fiscal responsibility, such as assigned chores, allowances, and the attitude that money doesn’t grow on trees, are often completely absent from these families. The typical excuses range from “I don’t want them to go through what I had to go through,” to “My children work so hard. I don’t want to place more of a burden on them,” to “Heck, they’re only young once. Let them enjoy themselves!”

Even more interesting is the fact that such practices are, in my experience, becoming more commonplace among families of more moderate incomes. Many families who clearly lack the means to “live high on the hog,” are nonetheless trying to live an aspirational life well beyond their means and sending commensurate signals to their children about money and what it takes to become a successful, happy, and contributing adult.

Of course, a popular culture that has a truly toxic view of wealth contributes further to the distorted and destructive relationship that families have with money. When the two most powerful forces — parents and popular culture — send the same harmful messages about money to children, what chance do they have to develop a healthy relationship with money and acquire the necessary maturity and fiscal skills to survive and thrive in the real world in which most of us live?

I can assure you that any of these attitudes, from well intentioned to cavalier, is a recipe for financial doom for children. Yes, childhood is a time to play, have fun, and not have to face the demands of adulthood. At the same time, childhood must also be a time to prepare children for adulthood. In other words, you must actively train your children for adulthood. Here’s how to think about it. Consider all the attitudes and skillsets necessary to be a functioning adult with a healthy relationship to money, for example, delayed gratification, respect, responsibility, discipline, cooperation, decision making, and promptness. Now ask yourself whether you are instilling those attitudes and teaching those skillsets in your children. Unless you plan to leave your children with a large trust fund and no expectations of doing anything substantial or meaningful in their lives, you are leaving them wholly unprepared for the “real world.”

Here’s an example of a father who, wanting to give his children everything, is leaving his children with little of substance or value. This father, I’ll call him David, had a very difficult upbringing in a high-net-worth family. David’s father was hard working and hard driving, expecting obedience and achievement in his son. At the same time, his father was perfectionistic, cold, and unloving. Added to that, an accident left David with a minor, though noticeable, disability.

David took the money he got from his father and, through hard work and savvy investing, parlayed it into a substantial fortune. He and his wife raised their children on a compound in the Western mountains and David was determined give his kids the childhood that he never had. Their property was like Neverland, a veritable amusement park with every plaything a child could want. David’s children never had to work for anything. He heaped them with love regardless of their behavior and bought them anything they wanted without asking anything in return. His children never had chores, responsibilities, expectations, or consequences placed on them.

What kind of children did David’s grow up to be? They were selfish, entitled, rude, disrespectful, irresponsible, out of control, and lazy. In two words, spoiled brats. Speaking of spoiled brats, I make a distinction between children who are spoiled (perhaps a better term is “fortunate”) and those who are spoiled brats. Both spoiled children and spoiled brats are given just about everything they want. The difference is that spoiled children are raised to take full advantage of the opportunities they are given and to be grateful for all that they have. Plus, they are asked give back in some form in return. In contrast, spoiled brats are not.

As long as David’s children stayed on the family compound, life was good because they played by the rules set by David (in other words, there were no rules). But problems arose when they entered the real world of school, sports, and relationships beyond the family. The children were simply incapable of functioning in a healthy way or taking care of themselves in the real world.

Though this example may seem extreme, it is far from the exception for children raised in high-net-worth families and, increasingly, among less-well-off families as well. Clearly, no parents intend to raise their children this way, whether wealthy or not, but it is a real risk when money — its acquisition, accumulation, and expenditure — becomes a defining value and force in a family.

(This article was also posted at Dr. Jim Taylor’s Blog.)

(Visit Dr. Jim Taylor’s YouTube channel to see television interviews and Prime topic discussions.)

Articles written by Dr. Jim Taylor
Tags: children, culture, discipline, money, responsibility, rich, spoiled brats
Categories: Education, Life, Science | Comments (4) | Home

4 Responses to “How to Raise Spoiled Brats”

Tom Carter | February 24th, 2011 at 4:39 am

Some parents are thoughtful enough to think things through and understand that there has to be a balance between the “Tiger Mom” approach to parenting and the “David” approach. Most, though, seem to just wing it and act consistently with their own personalities. Worse, some parents just don’t care and largely ignore their kids.

I repeat my totally unrealistic idea: Parents should have to have a license to have kids. We require training, testing, and licensing for many things in life, none of which are more important that raising children. Ah, well….

Clarissa | February 25th, 2011 at 12:07 am

I just blogged about this phenomenon when people in their 30ies still believe that they are entitled to their parents money and get very resentful when their parents dispose of their financial resources the way they want to. It’s mind-boggling to me how anybody can fail to understand that their parents’ financial obligations to them end when they reach the age of majority. Many parents choose to help out their children financially after that, but it’s their choice and any decision they make has to be respected.

Tom Carter | February 25th, 2011 at 6:19 am

Clarissa, I just read your post (you can always add links to comments if you wish). I couldn’t agree more that:

Many people tend to see their parents as property that belongs to them and that has no life, will or desires of its own. Parents are people, too. They are responsible for their children’s well-being until the children reach the age of majority. After that, they have no financial obligations to their children.

I know a woman in her 60s who is still working very hard supporting her disabled and ill husband plus contributing to the support of her two children, both in their 30s. It’s a choice she makes but not one I can understand or justify.

How NOT to Raise Spoiled Brats | Current News World Web Source for News and Information | March 6th, 2011 at 5:23 pm

[…] “How to Raise Spoiled Brats,” I described what I have seen as a rise in spoiled and fiscally irresponsible brats among […]